Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PJ's avatar

I like that you point out how the genre, mood, tone and audience all play a part in how to shape the opening of a story. Sometimes I find opening lines in some books a bit gimmicky? If that makes sense? Like the writer is trying too hard to grab your attention... but maybe that's just me. If I'm going to be manipulated, I don't want to be able to tell... I want to remain blissfully ignorant of the fact 😂 if my attention is grabbed too hard I switch off. But the stories that do this well have a sense of authenticity to them.... like that is genuinely the narrative vibe and personality of the story, so that's OK. And the ones that are a bit gimmicky don't seem able to maintain the initial vibe. Halfway through the first chapter it's like you're reading a different writer's work. I always tell my students that it's about voice more than anything. Does the story have a personality (another way of daying mood/tone, I guess) and can you tell what it is right from the start? Opening lines/scenes are hard to do well, but so important because they really are make or break for engaging most readers/audiences.

Expand full comment
The Amazing Montsta's avatar

I must be in the middle category, being an early millennial where my attention span isn't quite as fucked as other to come, but I liked the opening of Fellowship of the Ring, the explaining of the mythology really piqued my interest for what was to follow, so much that I brought all the books and read them multiple times. Would it work in a comic? Maybe not. But movies and books have a different sense of time and acceptance to them.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts